Randy was really and happy that it was both David’s on the stage. He felt he was the best singer of season 7.

Paula was left speechless, just like the last time. She felt he was stunning tonight.

Simon thought tonight was one of the great finals. He felt Archuleta came out to win and everyone witnessed a knockout.

Based on judges comments, mainly Simon’s, it would indicate that Archuleta will win the competition. However, it’s up to the fans. Only tomorrow will tell.

Randy wasn’t crazy about the song, but David was so in the zone that it was hot.

Paula felt it was another heartfelt performance.

Simon loved the egotistical lyric. He also felt that he picked the better song. And again, he felt the round went to Archuleta.

Awesome song!

Randy thought it was flawless and molten hot. Crazy vocals. Best performance of the season.
Paula got chills. She thought it was a beautiful performance.
Simon thought he was okay last week, but this performance was his best so far. Round one goes to Archuleta.

Even I have to concede that he did great!

David Archuleta’s last song of night was the Dan Fogelberg song “Longer,” which was picked by the show’s producers.

Randy felt it was an interesting song choice. It was another hot one.
Paula felt it was a lovely performance.
Simon felt he sang the song very well, however, he felt the song and the lyrics were absolutely horrible. It was gooey. *raises eyebrow* He felt he did enough to make it through to the finals next week. Can you say David and David next week?

David A.’s song choice for the night was “With You” by Chris Brown. Finally, something young and current. This could be a very good thing for him.

Randy applaud that he chose something new and young. But he wasn’t sure it was the right song.
Paula felt it was perfect. She thinks he should be singing songs like this.
Simon applaud that he didn’t do a ballad, however, he felt it was like a chihuahua trying to be a tiger. Meaning: It’s not really you.

Paula Abdul chose the Billy Joel song “And So It Goes” for her judges choice tonight for David Archuleta.

Randy was happy that Paula chose a dope song. He thinks David can sing whatever and that he’s in it to win it.
Paula felt it was a pure and stunning performance.
Simon thought it was very good, but didn’t contain any surprises. A bit predictable. He didn’t feel it was outstanding.

Tonight David Archuleta will be performing the following three songs as reported by TMZ.

1- “And So it Goes” - Billy Joel
2- “With You” - Chris Brown
3- “Longer” - Dan Fogelberg