Live Blogging American Idol

  • Brooke White Sings “You Must Love Me”

    07:29:25 pm on April 22, 2008

    Brooke White went third tonight. She chose a song from the film adaptation of Evita: “You Must Love Me“.

    Webber didn’t feel Brooke had a clue what she was singing about at first. He was quite pleased how she sang it after she grasped what it was about.

    Brooke messed up her lyrics again this week. Tsk tsk. Not good Brooke.

    Randy didn’t feel it was great. The one thing he liked was that she listened to Andrew Lloyd Webber. He felt vocally it was tough.
    Paula told her that she must never stop and start. However, she did love the fact that Brooke didn’t overact while she sang.
    Simon thought the beginning was dramatic. He felt it became uncomfortable. He told her she would be very disappointed when she watches it back. Simon did admit that he would have handled the beginning when she forgot her lyrics the same way that she chose to.

     

Leave a Comment