Live Blogging American Idol

  • Carly Smithson Sings “Without You”

    07:06:14 pm on April 15, 2008

    Tonight Carly Smithson performed second. She chose the song “Without You” from the Mariah Carey double-sided single, Never Forget You.

    Mariah felt she did a great job.

    Randy liked that she challenged herself with the big vocals but he thought she needed to trust herself more. It was pretty good. Paula liked that she showed some vocal restraints then soared. Simon really wanted to hear Carly sing the song before tonight but he didn’t feel she pulled it off.

     

Leave a Comment